People can buy and sell contracts linked to future events in prediction markets. As more people become interested in data-driven forecasting, Kalshi and PredictIt, two platforms that focus on the U.S., continue to receive considerable attention. Both employ similar contract mechanisms but differ substantially in rules, market scope, and long-term reliability.
Understanding what distinguishes each platform makes it easier to determine which is best for specific groups.
Kalshi vs. PredictIt Overview
| Feature | Kalshi | PredictIt |
|---|---|---|
| Launch Year | 2021 | 2014 |
| Regulatory Status | Fully regulated by the U.S. CFTC | Operating under legal dispute after the no-action letter revocation |
| Primary Focus | Macroeconomics, finance, policy, and political control | U.S. elections and political outcomes |
| Currency Used | USD | USD |
| User Access | U.S. residents only | U.S. residents only |
| Identity Verification | Required (KYC) | Required |
| Market Approval Process | All markets require CFTC approval | Limited to predefined political topics |
| Investment Limits | No low artificial caps | $850 per user per market |
| Trader Limits per Market | No fixed participant cap | 5,000 traders per market |
| Liquidity Potential | Higher, institution-friendly | Often limited by caps |
| Use Case | Hedging, speculation, and financial forecasting | Political analysis, research, and election tracking |
| Long-Term Stability | High, backed by regulation | Uncertain, dependent on court rulings |
Kalshi: Regulated Event Trading with Financial Focus
Kalshi is a CFTC-regulated event exchange operating legally in the United States. Launched in 2021, it became the first federally approved platform designed specifically for trading event contracts. Users trade with U.S. dollars and must complete identity verification, aligning Kalshi closely with traditional financial exchanges.
The platform focuses heavily on macro-level events. Markets commonly cover inflation rates, Federal Reserve decisions, unemployment data, GDP growth, and political control of U.S. institutions. Each market must receive regulatory approval before launch, which limits speed but ensures legal clarity and consumer protection.
Volatility on Kalshi markets varies by topic, but most contracts are designed to be straightforward and easy to interpret. Prices move as new data emerge, allowing users to hedge against real-world risks or express views on upcoming economic releases. Because there are no artificially low caps on participation, Kalshi supports higher liquidity than research-oriented platforms.
Kalshi’s primary advantage is credibility. Full CFTC oversight provides confidence for individuals and institutions looking to use prediction markets as financial tools rather than entertainment products. The trade-off is flexibility: markets are narrower in scope, and pop-culture or speculative topics rarely appear.
PredictIt: Political Forecasting with Strict Limits
PredictIt launched in 2014 as an academic research platform focused almost entirely on U.S. politics. It operates on a fiat currency and offers markets for elections, congressional control, and major policy decisions. Contracts trade between 1 and 99 cents and pay out $1 if the outcome occurs, making probability estimates easy to understand.
For years, PredictIt has been widely cited during election cycles for its historical accuracy and active user base. However, the platform operates under significant structural constraints. Each market is limited to 5,000 traders, and individual users may invest up to $850 per market.
Regulatory pressure has become PredictIt’s defining challenge. The CFTC took away the platform’s special no-action letter in 2022. This letter allowed the platform to conduct research under less stringent standards. There were legal issues, but PredictIt continues to operate while the court case is ongoing.
These problems make PredictIt less useful for large-scale prediction or risk management. In popular markets, liquidity can dry up rapidly, and position limits can impair price formation. The site is still useful for political junkies, analysts, and scholars who are interested in the results of U.S. elections.
Which Platform Is the Better Choice?
Kalshi is better suited for users seeking a legally compliant, financially oriented prediction market. Its regulated structure, higher liquidity potential, and expanding range of macroeconomic contracts make it appealing for serious forecasting and risk management.
PredictIt remains a niche platform best suited for political forecasting and educational use. Its simplicity and historical data still hold value, but regulatory uncertainty and hard limits restrict its long-term growth.
How the Two Platforms Stack Up Overall
Kalshi and PredictIt represent two distinct approaches to prediction markets. PredictIt helped popularize trading in political events, but its constrained model and legal challenges constrain its future. Kalshi, built from the ground up as a regulated exchange, positions prediction markets closer to mainstream finance.
For users prioritizing stability, legality, and broader real-world applications, Kalshi stands out as the stronger option. PredictIt still serves a purpose, but Kalshi reflects where regulated prediction markets are headed.
About the Author
